
Holiday light season is here, and one video has the internet arguing about phones. As PetaPixel reported on November 16, 2026, BBC London shared a clip of the Christmas lights switch-on on Carnaby Street in Central London. It shows a sea of people with nearly every phone held up in the air, filming the lights and the fireworks that followed.
The comments filled up fast. Many people were frustrated that almost no one seemed to be watching the moment itself. Some compared it to an episode of Black Mirror, others called the crowd “robots,” and plenty of people pointed out the irony of complaining about it while watching the video on a phone.
As event photographers in San Antonio, we see this at almost every celebration we cover. So here is what the debate gets right, what the research says, and how a simple photo plan lets your guests put their phones down and enjoy your event.
What the research says about photos and memory
- A 2013 museum study asked one group to tour an art museum and take photos, and another group to tour without a camera. The group that took photos was worse at identifying the objects later and remembered fewer details about them.
- A 2018 study suggested that taking photos or video can give people a false sense that they have preserved a moment, when really the camera did the remembering for them.
- The public mood is shifting. Dr. Kaitlyn Regehr of University College London and the University of Toronto told the BBC that watching events through screens is not new, but this year there is much more critical public conversation about it, which she sees as positive.
None of this means phones are bad. A quick snapshot to share with family is part of how people celebrate today. The problem is when everyone spends the whole moment framing a shaky clip they will never watch again.
Why a professional photographer changes the picture
When guests know a professional is covering the event, they relax. They watch the toast, the countdown, or the first dance with their own eyes because they know the good photos are coming. Look at the photo above: most of the guests along that aisle are simply watching. That is what a well-covered moment looks like.
A pro also gets angles no one in the crowd can. We plan positions ahead of the big moments, work from the aisle, the stage edge, or a higher vantage point, and time the shot for the peak instead of holding a phone up for three minutes. We shot this frame on our Nikon Z8, which we have used since launch, and its quiet electronic shutter lets us work close to a ceremony or a speech without adding noise to the room.
Five ways to help your guests live in the moment
- Tell guests the moment is covered. A line in the invitation, on a welcome sign, or from the emcee (“We have a photographer, so enjoy this with us”) goes a long way.
- Pick one or two “phones down” moments. You do not need a fully unplugged event. Ask for screens down during the vows, the keynote opening, the award reveal, or the lighting ceremony, then invite everyone to snap away afterward.
- Share a gallery link fast. When guests know they will get great photos soon, they film less. Ask your photographer about a quick preview set or an online gallery guests can visit after the event.
- Give your photographer the run of show. Share the schedule, the big moments, and any surprises ahead of time so we can be in the right spot before the countdown starts.
- Plan for the crowd. At light shows, fireworks, and holiday parties, the best spot is often claimed early. Talk with your photographer about a reserved position or a riser so the shot is not a wall of raised phones.
A tip for photographers shooting into a sea of phones
If you cover holiday events this season, expect raised arms and glowing screens. Get there early to claim your position, shoot from slightly above the crowd when you safely can, and use the phones as part of the story when they fit. A wide frame of a crowd lit by a hundred little screens can say a lot about the moment. Just keep faces small or get permission, especially at private events.
The takeaway
The Carnaby Street video struck a nerve because most of us have been that person with the phone in the air. The fix is not banning cameras. It is giving people a reason to trust that the moment is being captured well, so they can actually be there for it. That is exactly what a good event photographer is for.
Source: PetaPixel, “Backlash Over ‘Robots’ Taking Photos at Christmas Lights Event” by Matt Growcoot (November 16, 2026), reporting on a BBC London video shared November 4, 2026.
Planning a holiday party, gala, conference, or celebration in San Antonio or anywhere in Texas? Reach out to Grey Bug Photography, or see how we work with planners on our For Planners page.